Top Nonprofit Direct Mail Companies
Find the perfect provider to help you fundraise.
These are our favorite nonprofit direct mail companies.
Menu

Top Nonprofit Direct Mail Companies

These are our favorite nonprofit direct mail companies.

Direct mail fundraising is an effective choice for nonprofits of all shapes and sizes. Choosing the right fundraising partner to work with, however, can be a challenge.

That’s why we’ve put together this quick guide to help you find the right company to assist in your direct mail fundraising efforts. Let’s discuss the following nonprofit direct mail fundraising companies:

  1. Pledgemine
  2. AGP (Allegiance Group + Pursuant)
  3. Meyer Partners
  4. Salsa Labs
  5. Douglas Shaw & Associates
  6. HSP Direct
  7. Mal Warwick DonorDigital

Without further ado, let’s jump into our top suggestions!

Pledgemine

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

Pledgemine by EverTrue is an end-to-end mailing design tool and delivery service for nonprofits, universities, healthcare organizations, and other types of charitable organizations. With Pledgemine, nonprofits can make and distribute personalized mail at scale. Thanks to Pledgemine’s user-friendly templates, nonprofits can create customized, professional mailers without extensive design experience. 

From there, Pledgemine’s team will handle every step of the delivery process, including:

  • Order management, with no minimum requirements
  • Printing using high-quality materials 
  • Stamping, addressing, and delivery

After creating your designs, your team can relax and focus on donor stewardship while Pledgemine handles mailing logistics.

Pledgemine's homepage

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

Pledgemine is designed to operate at any scale. If you’re a small nonprofit that only needs a few hundred mailers, Pledgemine has no minimum order quantities, saving you costs and resources. If your nonprofit is having trouble personalizing mail for thousands of donors at scale, Pledgemine can handle that, too, thanks to its variable data personalization features. 

Pricing of This Nonprofit Direct Mail Company

Contact EverTrue to get a demo of Pledgemine and request pricing information.

Pledgemine's logo
Get started with Pledgemine!
Pledgemine's homepage

AGP (Allegiance Group + Pursuant)

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

AGP (Allegiance Group + Pursuant) is a full-service nonprofit marketing and fundraising agency that strives to help mid-sized to large nonprofits increase giving, elevate branding, and reach more supporters. With decades of experience, its team of expert strategists, data analysts, fundraisers, and creatives works together flawlessly to deliver impactful direct mail fundraising campaigns. 

AGP has merged to form a company that is dedicated to meeting the needs of its nonprofit clients, specializing in verticals like:

  • Arts & Culture
  • Education
  • Environment & Animal Welfare
  • Human Services

To meet all of your organization’s marketing and fundraising needs, the company offers direct mail fundraising, digital marketing, web and app development, UX and design services, and more!

AGP is a top nonprofit website design company

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

In addition to rigorous planning, strategizing, and creative work on its general marketing and direct mail campaigns, AGP offers a variety of cutting-edge nonprofit tech, including:

  • GivingDNA: A top-of-the-line wealth screening and data analytics tool that finds the insights and opportunities you need.
  • Allyra: A fundraising tool designed to help organizations create optimized donation forms and manage peer-to-peer fundraisers.
  • And More!

Visit the Allegiance Group + Pursuant website to browse its full list of offerings.

Pricing of This Nonprofit Direct Mail Company

Contact AGP for a custom quote on direct mail fundraising services.

AGP is a top nonprofit direct mail company
Get started with AGP!
AGP is a top nonprofit website design company

Meyer Partners

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

Meyer Partners is a full-service nonprofit marketing agency that has a standout record with direct mail fundraising campaigns. The Meyer Partners donor-centric approach prioritizes long-term donor value, so they always have an eye on cultivation and relationship-building.

Whether you aim to acquire new donors in your annual fundraiser or launch a disaster relief campaign, Meyer Partners’ powerful, personal direct mail appeals reach your audience’s hearts and minds to motivate them to act.

Meyer Partners also offers a host of data analytics services, so you can extract important data metrics from your direct mail campaigns.

Check out Meyer Partners' direct mail fundraising solutions.

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

Meyer Partners knows that effective, consistent messaging is key for reaching and retaining a diverse network of supporters through multiple channels, especially direct mail.

Meyer Partners works with your organization to help you develop the perfect direct mail fundraising strategies to meet your goals, maximize fundraising outcomes, and further your cause.

Check out Meyer Partners' direct mail features.
Get started with Meyer Partners!
Check out Meyer Partners' direct mail fundraising solutions.

Salsa Labs

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

As a top provider of nonprofit technology, it’s no wonder that Salsa Labs’ direct mail fundraising services are on our list.

Their CRM software allows nonprofits to craft professional fundraising appeals with their built-in word processor. 

Above all, Salsa’s direct mail solutions help nonprofits overcome donation obstacles and perfect winning fundraising strategies.

See how Salsa's direct mail fundraising solutions can help your organization.

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

With Salsa, your organization can capitalize on powerful mail merge tools to organize your email management.

Plus, you can even use bar code scanning for larger direct mail solicitations in an effort to simplify the process.

Pricing of This Nonprofit Direct Mail Company

Contact Salsa Labs for a quote on their nonprofit direct mail solutions.

Check out Salsa's direct mail features for nonprofits.
Get started with Salsa!
See how Salsa's direct mail fundraising solutions can help your organization.

Douglas Shaw & Associates

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

Douglas Shaw and Associates has focused their entire business on helping your nonprofit create the right donor communication using the most relevant channels.

They strive to move donors from “interest to action” with their direct mail fundraising solutions.

Douglas Shaw and Associates believe that as the most traditional fundraiser, the written word boasts incredible power.

See how Douglas Shaw and Associates can help your organization get a handle on your direct mail fundraising.

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

Douglas Shaw and Associates crafts personalized cultivation strategies for every nonprofit they work with, meaning they’ll never hand you a blanket approach and push you out the door.

They work with each nonprofit to understand the organization and create the best strategy for them. No two strategies are ever the same!

Pricing of This Nonprofit Direct Mail Company

Contact Douglas Shaw and Associates for a quote on their direct mail fundraising solutions.

Douglas Shaw and Associates is a top nonprofit direct mail company.
Get started with Doulgas Shaw and Associates!
See how Douglas Shaw and Associates can help your organization get a handle on your direct mail fundraising.

HSP Direct

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

HSP Direct’s staff brings creative copywriters with different backgrounds together to help your organization tell its story.

They know that the most successful fundraising appeals are the ones focused around your story. HSP Direct believes that since no donor is the same, no fundraising appeal should be the same either.

Don’t worry, they’ll even keep your budget in mind. One of their core values is using the most cost-effect practices.

See how HSP Direct's direct mail fundraising solutions can help your organization.

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

HSP Direct mentions that fundraising isn’t just a business to them, it’s something deeper. It helps fulfill their values.

When they find nonprofits who believe in fulfilling these values, they’re eager to help craft powerful messages that will inspire donors to act.

Pricing of This Nonprofit Direct Mail Company

Contact HSP Direct for a quote on their direct mail fundraising solutions.

HSP is a top nonprofit direct mail company.
Get started with HSP Direct!
See how HSP Direct's direct mail fundraising solutions can help your organization.

Mal Warwick DonorDigital

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Overview

With a team boasting over 35 years of experience, MWD Agency has provided direct mail services to nonprofit organizations natonwide.

MWD believes in helping your organization build strong, long-lasting donor relationships by extensive direct mail strategy.

They focus on the fundamentals: “strategy-driven creative, lots and lots of testing, sophisticated segmentation, and insightful analysis of what really works.”

Check out MWD's direct mail fundraising solutions for nonprofits.

Why We Love This Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraising Company

MWD Agency covers your direct mail fundraising efforts from start to finish with budgeting and forecasting, creative services like copywriting and design, comprehensive reporting, and more.

They hold your hand the whole way through so you’re never left in the dark.

Nonprofit Direct Mail Company Pricing

Contact MWD Agency for a quote on their direct mail fundraising solutions for nonprofits.

Mal Warwick Donordigital is a top nonprofit direct mail company.
Get started with Mal Warwick DonorDigital!
Check out MWD's direct mail fundraising solutions for nonprofits.

Additional Resources for Nonprofit Direct Mail Companies

Top Donor Management Software

Check out this guide to donor management software.

Looking to amp up your communications and fundraising strategies?

Check out our top donor management software providers to find the perfect solution for your organization that allows you to provide targeted outreach for donors.

Get started with our list of donor management software solutions!

Peer-to-Peer Fundraising Guide

Learn more about peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns with our extensive guide.

Interested in trying out a peer-to-peer fundraising campaign but have no idea where to start?

We’ve got your back. Check out our peer-to-peer fundraising guide for all the basics and some helpful pointers!

Get started with our peer-to-peer fundraising guide!

Best Fundraising Event Tools

Check out the top fundraising event software providers.

Planning a fundraising event to kick off your campaign?

Take a look at our list of the top fundraising event software and tools for nonprofits. You’re sure to find the perfect provider for your organization here!

Get started with our list of fundraising event tools!